Farmer Wants a Wife season 3 finale: Who Did the Farmers Choose?

Season finales are always full of emotion, but this time, Farmer Wants a Wife delivered more twists than anyone saw coming. From heartfelt moments to tearful exits, the final decisions made by Farmer Matt Warren, Farmer Jay Woods, Farmer John Sansone, and Farmer Colton Hendricks left both their ladies and fans stunned.

As the four men prepared to choose who they wanted to continue building a life with, tensions ran high—and some final choices left viewers with their jaws on the floor.

Jay Chooses Grace Over Karina, and Brings a Puppy Too

Jay Woods had narrowed it down to two strong connections: Karina and Grace. Both seemed like a perfect match, but in the end, Jay followed his heart and chose Grace. He praised Karina for being amazing and said she checked every box, but shared that his bond with Grace was simply stronger.

Dead & Company Kick Off Grateful Dead’s 60th Anniversary in Golden Gate Park: Every Song From Night 1

His decision was hard for Karina, but she remained graceful and understanding, even wishing him the best. Then came one of the sweetest moments of the finale—Jay gave Grace a puppy, calling her possibly the “love of my life.” Grace accepted his offer to continue their relationship and said she felt like she was exactly where she’s meant to be.

Colton Turns Down Keeley, Picks Zoe for a Slower Pace

Farmer Colton Hendricks had a tough decision between Keeley and Zoe. His reasoning? Time. Colton explained that his young son comes first, and he wasn’t ready to fully commit to a serious relationship that required too much too fast.

Why John Stamos Stepped In Last Minute for Josh Gad in Jesus Christ Superstar at the Hollywood Bowl

Keeley respected his honesty and appreciated that he didn’t just say what she wanted to hear. But Colton wasn’t leaving solo—he told Zoe he wanted to take things slow and see where their connection could go. Zoe accepted, and the two shared a kiss to seal their new beginning.

John Leaves Lily in Tears, Picks Claire as “The One”

Farmer John Sansone shocked Lily with his decision to end their relationship. Despite his kind words, Lily was clearly hurt, calling the goodbye “a lot harder” than she expected. Still, she wished him well with Claire.

John, who had said earlier he was confident in his decision, told Claire that she continued to surprise him and that he was ready to pursue a future with her. Their sweet moment ended with a creative surprise: he dropped the scarf she crocheted from above and wrapped her in it. Claire then gifted him a matching hat she had made. It was heartfelt, sincere, and a little quirky—just like them.

Logan Lerman Talks New Rom-Com ‘Oh, Hi!’ and Why Modern Dating Is So Complicated

Matt’s Final Choice Stuns Jordyn, But Chelsi Wins His Heart

Farmer Matt Warren had two strong women—Jordyn and Chelsi—but his final pick left Jordyn speechless. She thought they were on the same page, especially after their recent date where he reassured her. But Matt chose Chelsi, saying he felt a stronger connection with her.

Jordyn walked away upset, saying she felt misled and disappointed. Matt said he had been conflicted but was now sure about Chelsi. His heartfelt words to her made it clear he saw a real future: “When I’m not with you, I think about you.”

Chelsi was thrilled, saying she loved the outcome. And while Matt didn’t propose, he hinted at the future, saying, “I’m not gonna ask you to marry me today… but you better someday, because I’m never dating anyone else again.”