Jessica Simpson American Idol 2025 Finale Performance: What Really Happened?

The American Idol 2025 season finale was filled with surprises, but one moment that really stirred up social media was the unexpected appearance of Jessica Simpson. She performed live during the May 18 finale alongside rising artist Josh King, marking her first time back on the Idol stage in 15 years.

The show’s longtime host Ryan Seacrest introduced her return, sharing that Simpson would be singing her old hit “These Boots Are Made for Walkin’” and her new song “Blame Me” from her EP Nashville Canyon. Fans were quick to react. And not all of it was pretty.

Was Jessica Simpson’s Performance a Hit or a Miss?

Reactions were split, but the internet definitely didn’t hold back. Some fans praised her return, calling it iconic. Others, however, called her performance “cringe-worthy” and “hard to watch.”

Park Sung-hoon Opens Up About Playing Hyun-ju in ‘Squid Game’ Season 3

One viewer wrote on X, “The Jessica Simpson Josh King American Idol performance might be the most uncomfortable thing I’ve ever seen! Even the judges are cringing! His harmonica though…” Another chimed in with, “Luke’s face during that Jessica Simpson performance is the epitome of cringe.”

Yet not everyone felt the same. Some fans came to her defense. “Jessica Simpson crushed it,” one fan tweeted. Another said, “Jessica Simpson she absolutely killed it!!” proving that opinions were clearly divided.

Jerry Bruckheimer Reveals How Johnny Depp’s Jack Sparrow Almost Didn’t Make It Past Disney

What Songs Did Jessica Simpson Perform on American Idol?

Jessica kicked off with her classic hit “These Boots Are Made for Walkin’,” the song that helped shape her early 2000s pop image. She then moved into her newer track “Blame Me,” a country-influenced single from her latest project Nashville Canyon. The duet with Josh King added a surprise twist to the lineup, though not all fans were pleased with the pairing.

Some called the collaboration odd. Others mentioned Josh’s cowboy hat and harmonica as distractions. A post on X read, “Did not have Jessica Simpson on my #AmericanIdol finale Bingo Card — much less partnered with Josh King. Nor Josh in a cowboy hat. But it absolutely worked.”

Was the Performance Really That Bad?

Jessica Simpson has faced public criticism before, but this performance drew especially strong reactions. Some accused American Idol of booking random artists just for shock value. “Why the heck is Jessica Simpson on here lol,” one person posted. Another added, “Ewww! Jessica Simpson used to be able to really sing, but she sounds HORRIBLE tonight!”

Tom Sandoval Talks AGT, Villain Labels, and Life After Vanderpump Rules

Still, there’s no denying that Simpson had the guts to return to a massive stage after more than a decade. Her confidence, fashion choices (including a gold dress that caught a lot of attention), and bold pairing with Josh King made the moment memorable.

Whether fans loved it or hated it, Simpson’s performance got people talking. And sometimes, that’s the point.

Will Jessica Simpson Be Back on Stage Soon?

Despite the mixed feedback, Jessica seems to be embracing her musical comeback. With the release of her EP Nashville Canyon, she’s stepping back into the spotlight. While not everyone agreed with her American Idol performance, it’s clear that she still has a dedicated fan base cheering her on.

Whether she’ll do more live performances in the future remains to be seen, but one thing’s for sure: Jessica Simpson knows how to make headlines.