Which Peacock Shows Just Got Canceled Before the 2025-2026 TV Season?

If you’re a Peacock subscriber, you might want to brace yourself.
The streaming service has already pulled the plug on four shows ahead of the 2025-2026 season, as reported by Vulture.
And if you were a fan of any of these comedies or new series—well, it might sting a little.

Let’s take a closer look at what shows didn’t make the cut and what this might mean for the future of Peacock’s lineup.

Which Shows Did Peacock Cancel?

So far, Peacock has canceled four shows—and most of them were relatively new or comedy-based. Here’s the breakdown:

Dead & Company Kick Off Grateful Dead’s 60th Anniversary in Golden Gate Park: Every Song From Night 1

• “Mr. Throwback” — This comedy series was canceled in April after just one season.
• “Based on a True Story” — Another comedy, this one had a little more time, but still got canceled in April after two seasons.
• “Hysteria!” — Canceled back in February after only one season. Another comedy that didn’t seem to find its footing.
• “Teacup” — A horror series that was scrapped in January after just one season.

It’s clear that new shows and lighthearted comedies were especially vulnerable this year.

Why Are So Many Peacock Shows Getting Canceled?

Streaming platforms are under a lot of pressure right now.
With so many competitors like Netflix, Disney+, and Prime Video battling for attention, Peacock is likely tightening its lineup to focus on shows that either pull huge audiences or have strong long-term potential.

Why John Stamos Stepped In Last Minute for Josh Gad in Jesus Christ Superstar at the Hollywood Bowl

Newer shows often don’t get much time to build momentum—and comedies, in particular, can struggle if they don’t catch fire quickly with viewers.

It’s also worth noting that horror series like Teacup often face an uphill battle. Horror shows tend to be more niche compared to broader genres like drama or crime.

Could More Peacock Shows Be Canceled Soon?

Unfortunately, yes.

Logan Lerman Talks New Rom-Com ‘Oh, Hi!’ and Why Modern Dating Is So Complicated

Sources suggest that even more cancellations could be coming as the year goes on.
Peacock, like other streamers, regularly reevaluates its lineup based on viewership data, cost, and critical reception.
If a show doesn’t deliver in one or more of those areas, it can quickly find itself on the chopping block.

Fans of newer or lesser-known Peacock originals might want to keep an eye on updates throughout the rest of 2025.