Is Craig Conover Dating? Meet His Rumored Girlfriend Natalie Buffett

Well, well, well… looks like Charleston’s favorite pillow-making charmer might be off the market again.

On a recent episode of Watch What Happens Live (March 27), Craig Conover—yes, that Craig from Southern Charm—let it slip that he’s seeing someone new. After a very public relationship (and eventual breakup) with Summer House’s Paige DeSorbo, fans were eager to know: Is Craig Conover dating someone new in 2025?

Short answer? Yes. Long answer? Let’s dive in.

Who is Quentin Johnston? Meet the Los Angeles Chargers’ Rising Star After His Big Win

A classic Craig moment on WWHL

Craig sat alongside Southern Charm castmates Shep Rose and Austen Kroll, and when Andy Cohen brought up the topic of his love life, Craig couldn’t help but grin.

“Are you dating anyone… specifically?” Andy asked.

Craig replied with a smirk, “I am.”

Cue the Bravo audience gasp.

He didn’t name names, but then dropped a line that had gossip accounts buzzing:

“I’ve been reminded that the universe works in crazy ways. But everything happens for a reason.”

So who’s the mystery woman?

Who is Natalie Buffett?

Just hours after the WWHL episode aired, fan theories exploded. An anonymous tip to Deux Moi claimed that Craig’s new flame is Natalie Buffett—and if that name rings a bell, it’s probably because she dated NFL star Dak Prescott.

The plot thickens: the tip also claimed Natalie was spotted in the audience at the WWHL taping. That’s not exactly subtle, is it?

Natalie isn’t just “someone’s ex,” though. She’s a Texas native with a degree in civil engineering, the director of content at fitness-tech brand OxeFit, a certified yoga instructor, and a lowkey lifestyle influencer with a growing following. In short: she’s gorgeous, driven, and not new to the spotlight.

So… are they actually together?

Here’s the thing: neither Craig nor Natalie has publicly confirmed the relationship. No joint selfies. No flirty comments. Nothing Instagram official (yet).

But between Craig’s coy confirmation, Natalie allegedly attending the show, and whispers from sources “in the know,” there’s enough smoke to assume a little fire.

Could it just be a rumor? Maybe. But let’s be real—Craig isn’t exactly known for playing it cool when he’s excited about someone. The energy is definitely giving new relationship glow.

What about Paige?

Craig and Paige DeSorbo broke up sometime in 2024 after nearly three years together. Fans loved their Bravo crossover romance, but the couple ultimately parted ways due to “different life rhythms.” Paige is still thriving in NYC, focusing on her fashion and hosting career—and seems totally unbothered.

There’s no drama, no shade—just two people who grew apart. Craig even referred to her as “a huge part of my life” during his WWHL appearance.