Cristin Milioti Will Not Return as Sofia Falcone in The Batman Part II, Confirms Matt Reeves

The buzz around The Batman Part II is heating up, and fans have been eagerly asking one question: Will Cristin Milioti reprise her role as Sofia Falcone? After her Emmy-winning performance in The Penguin, viewers hoped she’d make the jump to the big screen in Matt Reeves’ next installment.

Unfortunately, director Matt Reeves has now confirmed that Milioti will not be appearing in The Batman Part II. The revelation came during an interview with Joshua Horowitz at the 2025 Emmys, as reported by SuperHeroHype, citing MTV.

So what exactly did Reeves say, and what does it mean for the Batman universe moving forward? Let’s break it down.

Gen V Season 2 Release Date, Time, Episodes & Schedule

Why Cristin Milioti Isn’t in The Batman Part II

In his conversation with Horowitz, Reeves had nothing but praise for Milioti’s work in The Penguin. He called her performance “astonishing” and described the creation of Sofia Falcone as “exciting” and full of potential.

However, Reeves explained that the script for The Batman Part II was already deep in development by the time Milioti’s breakout role aired. He said,

Robert Redford and Paul Newman: A Rare Hollywood Friendship

“Cristin’s not in this one, but that’s because we were so deep into the script by the time we were in the show.”

He went on to say that while her character was compelling, adding her into the new film would’ve disrupted the story they had already built.

“There are some things where it’s like, oh, we’d love to do this, but actually that doesn’t fit within where the story goes.”

What About Future Appearances?

Despite her absence from Part II, Reeves hinted that Milioti’s Sofia Falcone might not be gone for good.

“It would be really exciting to do something with her,” Reeves added, keeping the door open for potential future projects.

Even Cristin Milioti herself addressed the rumors in an interview with ExtraTV. She said,

Ned Fulmer Breaks Silence on Cheating Scandal After 3 Years

“I don’t know. I haven’t been told anything, and I don’t think so, but I would love to revisit her again.”

So while Sofia won’t appear in the 2026 movie, it’s possible that Milioti’s character could return in a later installment—or another spin-off in the expanding Gotham universe.

What’s Next for The Batman Part II?

Matt Reeves confirmed that The Batman Part II will begin filming in 2026, likely between late April and early May. The film will once again star Robert Pattinson as Bruce Wayne/Batman.

Reeves is co-writing the script with Mattson Tomlin, and details about the plot are being tightly guarded. In fact, Reeves joked that the script is kept in a “secret pouch with a lock on it,” underscoring how serious the team is about preventing leaks.

While little is known about the storyline, Reeves did hint that certain characters and plot arcs are still being explored behind the scenes. Now that the prep work is nearly complete, more creative decisions are expected to follow.

Cristin Milioti’s Rise with The Penguin

Milioti’s performance in The Penguin left a major impression. She played Sofia Falcone, the sharp and calculating daughter of crime boss Carmine Falcone. Her portrayal earned her an Emmy Award in 2025 for Outstanding Actress in a Limited Series.

The HBO spin-off, which is set in the same gritty Gotham world as The Batman, expanded on the city’s criminal underworld. Milioti’s Sofia emerged as one of the series’ standout characters, making her omission from the main film all the more surprising for fans.

Still, the recognition she received might ensure she isn’t gone for good.

Final Thoughts

Cristin Milioti may not appear in The Batman Part II, but her impact on the franchise is undeniable. Matt Reeves’ decision to keep her out of this particular chapter seems to be rooted in storytelling coherence rather than a lack of interest.

The door is open for Sofia Falcone’s return—and if fan enthusiasm is any clue, Milioti might just have another Gotham appearance in her future.

Are you excited for The Batman Part II? Let us know what you think—and who you hope to see in the next chapter of this dark and complex universe.