The world of TV shows has a unique way of making fans believe in the chemistry between its stars, and the case of Jesse Lee Soffer and Tracy Spiridakos from Chicago P.D. is no different. Their on-screen relationship as Jay Halstead and Hailey Upton captured hearts, but now fans are asking: Has their fictional romance spilled over into real life?
The dating rumors surrounding Soffer and Spiridakos have taken over the Chicago P.D. fandom, and recent social media activity and public appearances have only added fuel to the fire. Let’s dive into everything we know about whether these two stars are more than just friends.
On-Screen to Off-Screen: The Start of the Speculation
Jesse Lee Soffer and Tracy Spiridakos first met on the set of Chicago P.D., the popular NBC procedural drama where they played love interests. Their characters, Jay Halstead and Hailey Upton, shared a deep bond that fans couldn’t get enough of. But after their respective exits from the show, fans began to wonder if their chemistry extended beyond the screen.
Soffer, now 41 years old, has been a household name thanks to his time on Chicago P.D., as well as previous roles on As the World Turns. Spiridakos, 37, is equally beloved, with her impressive career including appearances on shows like Revolution and Bates Motel. Both actors have kept their personal lives relatively private, but their recent interactions have sparked curiosity.
Social Media Clues: A Possible Romance?
One of the biggest reasons fans believe Jesse and Tracy might be dating is their activity on social media. Following their exits from Chicago P.D., the duo has been spotted spending time together and posting about their adventures. For instance, in 2024, they enjoyed a vacation in Portugal shortly after Spiridakos left the show. Tracy shared a series of photos from Lisbon on Instagram, including a selfie with Jesse. The pictures captured the two enjoying the sights, dining together, and looking very much like a pair having a great time.
Their social media interactions didn’t stop there. Both actors frequently comment on each other’s posts, share behind-the-scenes images, and post birthday shoutouts. While these could simply be signs of a close friendship, fans can’t help but read between the lines. Could their playful banter and sweet posts hint at something more?
Public Appearances Together
Beyond social media, Jesse and Tracy have also been seen together at various public events. Back in 2017 and 2018, they posed together at the One Day Chicago event, looking every bit like a dynamic duo. More recently, they teamed up in 2023 to support the SAG-AFTRA strike, demonstrating their solidarity and shared values.
Their camaraderie and comfort with each other have been evident at these events, leading fans to wonder if their bond goes beyond mere friendship. While the pair remains tight-lipped about the nature of their relationship, their appearances together suggest a strong connection.
Their Personal Lives: Age, Family, and Net Worth
Jesse Lee Soffer, born on April 23, 1984, grew up in Ossining, New York. Over the years, he’s built an impressive career, with his portrayal of Detective Jay Halstead earning him widespread acclaim. As of 2025, his net worth is estimated to be around $5 million, thanks to his roles on TV and various endorsement deals.
Tracy Spiridakos, born on February 20, 1988, hails from Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada. Her Greek heritage and bubbly personality have made her a standout in Hollywood. Spiridakos’ net worth is estimated at $2 million, reflecting her successful acting career and brand partnerships.
While both actors have been linked to other relationships in the past, neither has publicly confirmed a significant other in recent years. This has only fueled speculation that their closeness might point to a romantic relationship.
What Do the Fans Think?
Fans of Chicago P.D. are divided on the topic. Some believe that Soffer and Spiridakos are simply good friends who share a deep bond after years of working together. Others are convinced that their chemistry on the show mirrors their real-life connection. Social media platforms like Twitter and Instagram are filled with fan theories, memes, and wishful thinking about the pair.
“They’re definitely dating! Did you see their Portugal pictures?” one fan commented on Instagram. Another wrote, “Even if they’re just friends, I love how close they are. Their bond is so genuine.”
Keeping It Private
One thing that stands out about both Jesse and Tracy is their commitment to keeping their personal lives private. While they’ve shared glimpses of their friendship online, they’ve avoided addressing the dating rumors directly. This approach aligns with their history of maintaining a low profile when it comes to relationships.
Their decision to stay silent on the matter could be out of respect for their privacy or simply because there’s nothing to confirm. Either way, fans will have to wait for more clues—or an official statement—to know the truth.
Could Friendship Be the Answer?
It’s entirely possible that Jesse Lee Soffer and Tracy Spiridakos are just close friends. Their years of working together on Chicago P.D. likely created a strong bond, and their shared experiences might explain their apparent closeness. Friendship in Hollywood is often mistaken for romance, especially when two stars share such undeniable chemistry.
Their public support for each other, from attending events to promoting each other’s work, is a testament to their respect and admiration. Whether or not they’re romantically involved, one thing is clear: they have a connection that goes beyond the superficial.
Conclusion: Are They or Aren’t They?
So, are Jesse Lee Soffer and Tracy Spiridakos dating? The answer remains unclear. While their social media posts, public appearances, and undeniable chemistry have fueled speculation, neither has confirmed a romantic relationship. For now, fans will have to settle for the mystery and enjoy watching their favorite stars thrive in their respective careers.
One thing is certain: whether as friends or something more, Jesse and Tracy share a special connection that has captured the hearts of many. Here’s hoping for more Instagram updates, red carpet moments, and maybe even a reunion on screen—because these two clearly have a bond worth celebrating.