American Idol Top 5 Revealed After Emotional Disney Night and Mother’s Day Tributes

American Idol just gave fans one of the most heartfelt episodes of the season. Episode 16 was a double dose of emotions, big performances, and of course, plenty of Disney magic.

With the competition now down to just five singers, it’s clear we’re getting close to the finish line. But before we get there, let’s take a look at all the standout moments, the surprise eliminations, and the five singers still chasing the crown.

Disney Night Returns with an Extra Twist

Disney Night is nothing new for Idol, but this year, they gave it the red carpet treatment. The show brought in none other than Lin-Manuel Miranda to help coach the Top 7 contestants through their performances. Each singer tackled a song from the Disney and Pixar vault, and the results were equal parts magical and emotional.

AGT 2025: Why Magician Mastermind Withdrew Before Semifinals

Whether it was the iconic melodies or the childhood nostalgia, Disney Night once again gave the contestants a chance to connect with fans on a different level.

Carrie Underwood and a Mother’s Day Full of Tears

As if singing Disney songs wasn’t enough, the second half of the episode leaned into full-on emotion. Carrie Underwood showed up dressed like she just stepped out of Alice in Wonderland and clearly had a hard time holding back tears as the contestants took the stage for Mother’s Day tributes.

AGT 2025 Results: Who Made Semifinals and Who Went Home

This section of the night brought out a new level of vulnerability in the performances.

Breanna Nix nearly broke down while singing Lauren Alaina’s “Like My Mother Does”. She struggled to push through the tears, but the raw emotion made the moment unforgettable.

Then came Thunderstorm Artis, who sang an original song for his wife, Faith, titled “Out of the Blue.” As he sang about her green eyes and their love story, she stood in the audience with their sons, visibly emotional. It was easily one of the night’s most memorable performances.

Steve Burton and Wife Michelle Launch 21-Day Reset & Rise Challenge

Ryan Seacrest Has a Moment of His Own

In a rare personal moment, host Ryan Seacrest gave fans a laugh with a little vulnerability of his own. After hearing Thunderstorm’s heartfelt lyrics, he joked,
“I’ve never been more depressed to be single than in this moment.”

And honestly, same, Ryan.

Who Went Home on ‘American Idol’?

After a long journey, two contestants said goodbye.

• Mattie Pruitt, the youngest singer in the competition, was eliminated.
• Gabby Samone, the powerful voice from Baltimore, also left the show.

Both singers had memorable runs and gained loyal followings, but the fan vote was tough this week, and there just wasn’t room for everyone.

Meet the American Idol Top 5

Here are the five finalists still in the running to become the next American Idol:

• Slater Nalley – Known for his smooth delivery and stage charm
• Breanna Nix – Emotional powerhouse who keeps getting better
• John Foster – Steady and strong, with a growing fanbase
• Jamal Roberts – Soulful singer with a unique style
• Thunderstorm Artis – A fan favorite with original music and a heartfelt voice

With this group, anything can happen. Each of them has had standout performances, and now it all comes down to who can connect with the audience the most in these final weeks.

Stay tuned. The next American Idol is getting closer to being crowned.